There’s nothing quite like fresh Gulf seafood—plump shrimp, sweet oysters, flaky fish—when it’s cooked just right. But even here on the Mississippi Coast, where the bounty of the Gulf is at our doorstep, it’s surprisingly easy to get it wrong. The two most common mistakes? Buying old seafood and overcooking it.
Fresh seafood smells fresh—never fishy. If you can smell it before you pick it up, don’t. Another telltale sign: the eyes. Fresh fish eyes are as clear as that old sober aunt you see at the family reunions. A fine cut of beef might age well and gain character over time, but seafood is at its very best the day it comes out of the water.
One of the best ways to buy seafood—especially shrimp from the Mississippi Sound or the Gulf of Mexico—is to head to the Biloxi Small Craft Harbor around 9 a.m. The boats that went out the night before are just coming in, and many sell shrimp (and sometimes fish) right off the stern. Look for boats with nets on board; it’s a good sign the catch is theirs. Occasionally, you might run into someone selling someone else’s shrimp of unknown age—but that’s rare.
If you’re buying from a fishmonger, ask where the seafood came from and how old it is. You might be surprised to learn it’s sometimes cheaper to farm-raise shrimp in Thailand and ship it 10,000 miles to the U.S. than to buy the ones caught just south of here. But freshness is worth the extra few dollars—it’s the difference between a meal and a memory.
When it comes to cooking, remember: speed is your friend. Shrimp or oysters deep-fry in just over a minute. Every second beyond that will make them tough and dull the delicate flavor. Sautéing takes only a little longer. And yes, overcooking is just as common in restaurants as at home—sometimes the chef simply forgets the timer.
Seasoning matters, too. Salt may have a bad reputation with doctors, but it’s a flavor intensifier. Under-salt, and you’re missing the full experience. My favorite seasonings are made by Gustus Vitae—especially their Italian blend and fresh herb mixes, which you can find on Amazon.
The secret to perfect seafood is simple: buy it fresh, cook it fast, and season it well. Do that, and you’ll taste the Gulf in every bite—clear-eyed and full of flavor.